“Systems Work, People Fail”

I’ve seen that headline on a site that’s making the rounds of traffic exchanges.

The implication is that people can only make money online with the right system, and that with the right system, anyone can do it.

I don’t like the headline, because it’s designed to appeal to people who lack confidence in themselves. The “system” mentioned will invariably turn out to be something that a new member must pay into until they start making a profit. Often the system involves one or more MLM programs.

So you take a person who doesn’t think they can succeed, and ask them to spend money until the “system” gets them into profit.

Well, this post is turning into more of a rant than anything else. But as part of research for the blog, I see so many systems that are thinly disguised ways to make money for the founders of the system. They’re all based on the idea that people can be sucked into the system in ever increasing numbers.

Ultimately, the system fails because people are only getting into it to make money, and it takes longer and longer to get each person into profit (since they’re all based on MLM programs).

How much harder would it be to offer a program that people truly need, and are willing to pay for, and also teach them how to use the program to improve their own Internet marketing efforts? And, as a bonus, help them get into profit faster than they might on their own.

One of these days I’d love to see a headline on a traffic exchange that reads, “Systems Fail, People Empower People”.

Project Payday Review

I’d intended for this to be a more comprehensive review, but picked up the flu over the weekend. So I’ll follow up with posts next week that cover more detail.

Project Payday‘s website says it can provide “Realistic Extra Income for the Average Joe”.

It’s refreshing to see a website that doesn’t claim to tell you how to make a million dollars in 30 days or double your money back. The slogan at Project Payday makes me feel like anyone can do this. It isn’t clear, though, what this is from reading the front page. There is an interesting guarantee, though…if you follow the instructions they give you, and don’t make money within 24 hours, they’ll pay you $100.

Project Payday is free, as long as you complete a sponsor offer. Those of you who have been around the Get Paid To (GPT) industry will recognize this as you performing an action that provides Project Payday with an affiliate commission. This is the first site I’ve seen that provides this alternative to simply paying for access.

Once you get in, there’s the predictable OTO (one time offer). You can upgrade and earn higher commissions from your own referrals to Project Payday. Again, you can upgrade by simply completing an offer. The standard commission is $1.50 per referral. Upgrading raised that to $2.00 for me.

One of the nicest things about Project Payday’s referral program is that they pay you for leads, not for activations. You get paid when someone fills out the form on the front page, regardless of whether that person completes an offer to activate their membership or not.

So what is the way that Project Payday gives you “realistic extra income”?

As you might expect from how the site uses GPT offers, the income comes from the GPT industry. But not the side of the industry I’d expected. I’d expected another site like Cash Crate that pays you to complete offers, essentially splitting the referral commission with you.

Instead, Project Payday includes an impressive set of training articles and videos that teaches you how to make money from the various “free item” sites. You’ve probably seen them around, the “get a PS3 for free” sort of site. What you generally have to do is complete one or more offers at the site, and refer some number of friends who do the same.

Project Payday shows you how to make money from these sites in three separate ways.

1) Get paid to help others get their free items.
2) Find sites that will give you cash in place of an item, and then pay others to help you get it
3) Pay others to help you get an item, and then sell it on Ebay

They also offer a mentoring program, where you can request a couple of mentors to be assigned. Mentors must be using the system successfully, so you know that you’ll get good advice.

Click here for the Project Payday site.

Update: See Project Payday Pays You To Join for more info on this program.

The Wall of Blogs

I figured I’d plug Enkay Blog‘s latest project (better late than never!)

The Wall of Blogs is a way to get a permanent link back to your blog, and to get some advertising at the same time. You can see the original announcement here.

This is similar to the pixel purchase sites that pop up now and then. I typically stay away from these sorts of projects for a few reasons.

1) The amount of space you get isn’t really worth it. You get a tiny space to fit a blog logo into, so the advertising value is almost non existent.

2) The sites themselves need to gain PR to give you much value for the link, and there are a lot of clone sites out there competing for attention.

I did purchase three blocks on The Wall of Blogs, though, for these reasons:

1) Well, it’s done by Enkay, which makes it cool!

2) You get a lot of space, plenty to show a blog logo so it’s actually readable.

3) I expect all the blogs that buy space will post about it and link to The Wall of Blogs, because of #1 and #2, so in the next PR update a link from it could be a nice boost.

I found out about The Wall of Blogs late, since I’ve been neglecting my RSS reader again. So I ended up with the first set of blocks on level 2 of the site. The plan is to rotate ads, though, so every ad will display above the fold for at least a few days during the month. This is a great move, and provides continuing value even to late adopters.

At $5 a block, this is one of the best values in pixel advertising I’ve seen.

Go get your blocks now!

Squidoo Earnings Update

Squidoo has just released its latest earnings update.

This update covers the month of July. My total earnings for July were $13.26, compared to $9.49 for the previous period.

Some highlights: Computer Game Making For Kids earned $4.12, up from $3.80. Roleplaying With Kids also earned $4.12, up from $3.80. My personal lens, Who Is Jay Shaffstall? earned $.04, down from $.65.

The main factor in these earnings figures is traffic (this is all Adsense sharing revenue). I’ve basically allowed Google to send me what traffic it wanted, without doing anything in the way of traffic building.

Will this continue to rise? With the additional lenses I’ve created, I imagine so.

How does this compare to running your own blog with adsense? Poorly. Your earnings from a blog running adsense will be higher, because you’re not sharing anything with Squidoo. But, a blog that covered as many diverse topics as my lenses cover probably wouldn’t get much in the way of regular readers.

Plus, creating a Squidoo lens is dead simple and free, while starting up a blog does have some overhead and cost associated with it.

If you have a topic about which you’re passionate and plan to generate a lot of content about, start a blog.

If you have a topic you want to put up a quick single page about, create a Squidoo lens.

Yuwie First Month Report

The month of August has come and gone, and the first set of earnings are available at Yuwie.

I ended up with a total of 22,879 page views between myself and my referrals. The amount paid out per 1,000 page views was $0.47. Depending on what level a page view was generated on in the referral tree, I ended up with some percentage of that $0.47.

Here’s a screenshot that shows the percentage and amount earned at each level:

Yuwie August Earnings

Now, $0.66 for the month probably doesn’t seem like much. Some points to keep in mind.

1) Most of my referrals were not active. Many people signed up to have a look around, and then apparently decided Yuwie wasn’t right for them at the time.

2) Since they weren’t active, most of my referrals did not get referrals of their own. So my referral tree is more of a pole, with relatively the same number of people at each level. At each level, very nearly one person is responsible for all the referrals on the next level.

3) In a single month, my referral tree grew down to level 7.

4) In the first six days of September, I have nearly half as many page views from referrals as in the entire month of August.

5) You earn three times as much from your level 10 referrals as you do yourself.

So, my conclusions from this are that you have to be in Yuwie for the long-term benefit. To get to the point of making serious money, you need active referrals all the way down an expanding tree. You can’t really do much about referrals being active or not, but for those that are active you can help them to build up their own set of referrals, and encourage them to do the same for their referrals.

This will help to expand the tree, which is where your earnings potential lies. If the tree expands all the way down to level 10, you’ve suddenly got a pretty nice income.

Luckily, getting referrals to Yuwie is pretty easy, as shown by #3 above. Most of my referrals come from online efforts, but most of their referrals come from friends and family they’ve told about Yuwie. Those are the people who will tend to be more active, because you know them outside of Yuwie.

Here’s a guide I wrote about getting the most out of Yuwie. It’ll give you an idea about what’s required to get results.

Click here to see what Yuwie is all about.

POAD Team Pro Upgrades Available

The POAD Team traffic exchange (previously known as the Power of a Dollar exchange) is now offering pro upgrades.

At $11 a month, the pro upgrade gives you 60 surfing credits each month, increased commissions from your referrals’ purchases, a better surfing ratio for your own surfing, and free referrals from people who join the site without a referrer.

The price isn’t out of line for pro upgrades at exchanges. The number of surfing credits you receive seems small, but remember that each visitor is reading your page to answer your question, so the value you get from each visitor should be higher than at a typical exchange.

They also offer a lifetime pro upgrade, currently priced at $497. In addition to the pro upgrade, you get a bunch of software and other bonuses. Since it would take a bit over three and a half years to get to $497 at the normal monthly upgrade cost, I don’t see the lifetime upgrade as a good deal. Especially for a new exchange that might not be around in two years, let alone four.

On the other hand, to get started with the POAD Team traffic exchange and push some visitors to your site to see if the whole concept of the exchange works for you, a single month’s upgrade gives you instant credits to work with.

If you can’t make a sale with 60 visitors who are reading your page, that’s probably a good indicator that what you’re selling doesn’t appeal to the POAD Team crowd, and you can cancel your subscription.

I’d be interested in hearing what other people’s results are with the exchange.

The September “No Contest” Contest

With the fall semester still getting into swing, I don’t have the time to manage a contest like August’s or the creativity to come up with a cute angle.

So September is the “No Contest” contest. The winner will be randomly chosen from amongst the people on the top commentators’ list just after midnight (EST), September 30th, 2007. That’s a maximum of ten pieces of paper I need to make up for my high tech contest system.

You don’t have to be at the top of the list, just somewhere in it. Since the two bottom entries in the list right now have 1 comment each, this should be an easy contest to enter. Just leave a comment or two, and the chances are good you’ll be entered.

The prize?

What about a discount on two years of premium quality web hosting at Site 5? Here’s the deal: Site 5 has a terrific web hosting deal where, by paying for two-years in advance, you can get the price down to $5 a month for more space and bandwidth than you’ll ever use.

Since I’m an affiliate of Site 5, if the contest winner buys through my link I get a commission. I’ll forward that commission back to the winner, giving them an effective discount. The exact amount they’ll get back depends on which hosting package they end up choosing.

And if the contest winner doesn’t need web hosting? We’ll work out another prize that’s mutually satisfactory.

Million Dollar Wiki

I’m sure you’ve all heard about the Million Dollar Wiki by now.

If not, here’s the short version: a guy named Graham wants to pay off his debt and open a bar in Boston, so he decides to start a wiki and sell pages on it at $100 each. He’s currently sold 445 pages as of this writing.

Why should you want to buy a page?

Well, Graham says the page will stay up for a minimum of 15 years. That’s about $7 a year. Since the concept is new, the Million Dollar Wiki is getting a lot of attention, which means visits for your page. You can use the page like you would a Squidoo lens, to either sell something or direct visitors to your main site, or both.

Pages on the wiki are sold based on keyword, which becomes part of the page’s URL and title. John Chow snapped up the page for make money online, predictably enough. The most popular page so far is one about Socially Responsible Business.

You can put Adsense on your pages, you can track them with Google Analytics, the works. You can even, if you want to, use iframes to put a forum in the page.

At $7 a year, I couldn’t resist. I picked up the page for the keyword Make Money Online Free and put together a first draft at a page designed to highlight various free money opportunities available online.

Have a keyword you’ve always wanted to rank for on Google? Check out the Million Dollar Wiki and see if it’s available there.

August Contest Results

The August “Win Me As A Slave” contest results are in!

You can see the number of entries each contestant had at the scoreboard post. I again used the high-tech method of writing entries on pieces of paper and drawing them out of a bucket. Before I do another contest that will have multiple entries per person, I need to write a computer program to automate that part!

I’m pleased to announce that the winner, as drawn randomly from the bucket, was Lori!

Lori gets me as her own slave for a task that requires up to a few hours (all at once, or spread out). From previous comments Lori’s made, I suspect that will mean setting up WordPress for her, complete with my spam-free settings and favorite plugins.

Congratulations Lori, and contact me via email once you’re ready to collect.

Also, Bohemian Bloggers never responded to emails notifying them they won one of the articles from the July contest (the danger of a Yahoo email address?), so I randomly drew between the two remaining blogs for that category. And the new winner is Tyson, over at Some Make Money.

Tyson, you’ll get a custom written article posted at EzineArticles.com, linking to two URLs of your choosing.

The Power of 10 Review

I ran across the Power of 10 the other day.

It’s an Internet marketing newsletter that claims you can generate $111,110 in 60 days. The newsletter is in prelaunch right now, but is supposed to launch Sept 4th. Unless you’re new to Internet marketing, you know that “prelaunch” really means, “get enough members so we can justify writing the newsletter”. I’ve timed this post to be published Sept 3rd, so you’ll have time to sign up before the first newsletter goes out.

As a bonus, they pay you $1 for every subscriber you refer to them. It gets better…you also get $1 for each subscriber one of your referrals refers. All the way down 5 levels. That’s where the $111,110 comes from, assuming you refer 5 people, they refer 5 people, and so on. You are limited to making a bit over $200,000, because they’ll only pay for a certain number of referrals on each level (unlimited on first level, 100 on second level, 1,000 on third level, and so on).

All told, they’re paying out $5 per subscriber. This tells you that they feel they can make money from the subscribers. There will be some links in the newsletter that will earn them money when you buy through them. What distinguishes a great newsletter from spam is whether their reviews are unbiased. We’ll have to see.

They’re also making money on the back end, by only making payments through Piggy-eBank.com. Dig a little on both sites, and you’ll see that they’re owned by the same people. Again, nothing wrong with that, it’s only smart to make sure you get money out of your visitors in as many ways as possible.

The fact that they’re funneling payments through their own payment processor is encouraging for the content of the newsletter. They’re clearly not beginners at Internet marketing, and have some experience to share.

So how does the 60 days figure into it? Well, when you sign up there’s a One Time Offer. You can pay $10 to have the earnings limit removed, and that also gets you into their rotator. They guarantee that you’ll get 10 referrals from their rotator, which will pay you your $10 back. If each of your referrals also paid the $10 to get into the rotator, you’d quickly get a decent amount of cash.

Note that there’s currently a delay in deposits being processed through Piggy-eBank.com, so it’s likely you won’t be able to sign up for the OTO anyway.

Click here to sign up for the newsletter.

Update: on September 4th, they changed the launch date to be September 25th. This isn’t the first time they’ve pushed the launch back. Given that their back office lists over 7,500 subscribers, it makes you wonder why the delay. Either they’re having technical issues, which is always possible, or they’re holding out for more subscribers.